Veteran Owned. Veteran Focused. Initial claims and appeals No fee for an initial claim VA-accredited attorney

A Quiet Win for Secondary Claims: The 'But-For' Standard After Spicer

A U.S. federal courthouse (U.S. Post Office and Courthouse, New Bern, North Carolina)

Some of the strongest VA disability claims are secondary claims. These arise where a condition VA already accepts (a service-connected disability) leads to a second problem. A 2023 federal court decision, Spicer v. McDonough, 61 F.4th 1360 (Fed. Cir. 2023), changed how VA has to look at these claims, and it did so in veterans’ favor.

The facts show why it matters. Mr. Spicer had service-connected leukemia, rated at 100%. The medications that kept his cancer in check lowered his blood counts so far that a needed knee-replacement surgery was canceled. Because he has to stay on those medications for life, the surgery could never happen. VA denied him secondary service connection for his knees. The Board said that being unable to have surgery because of his leukemia did not count as a secondary condition.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit disagreed. It held that the governing law requires compensation whenever a service-connected disability is a “but-for” cause of a current disability. The court said that this standard is broad, and undisputedly broader than “proximate cause.” The court based this on the compensation statute itself, 38 U.S.C. § 1110, and its identical peacetime version, § 1131 (which governed Mr. Spicer’s own claim), not on VA’s secondary-claim regulation. A condition can count as secondary if it “would have been less severe were it not for the service-connected disability,” including when a service-connected condition gets in the way of treating another problem. The court also held that, to the extent VA used part of its own regulation, 38 C.F.R. § 3.310(b), to deny this kind of claim, the regulation conflicts with the statute and is unlawful.

Why does this reach so many veterans? Secondary claims are very common: sleep apnea tied to another condition, mental health conditions tied to chronic pain, and countless others. Spicer tells VA to take a wider view of how one service-connected problem can make a second condition worse, even indirectly.

In practice, most secondary claims turn on a medical opinion. After Spicer, the question for the doctor is not only whether the service-connected condition caused the second problem. It is also whether the second problem would be less severe without the service-connected condition, including because that condition blocked treatment. An opinion that answers only the first question may miss the claim.

If a service-connected condition has made another health problem worse, or made it harder to treat, you may have a secondary claim worth pursuing. We help veterans build secondary service-connection claims and hold VA to the broader standard the courts now require.

Sources

  1. Spicer v. McDonough, 61 F.4th 1360 (Fed. Cir. 2023)
  2. 38 C.F.R. § 3.310

Talk with Veteran Claims Lawyer

We're a veteran-owned firm that helps veterans with VA disability claims and appeals. You can reach us through our contact page.